Stanford Legislation University — Robert Crown Rules Library

Finest Court from Ca

• Viewpoint
• Docket

Some body v. Figueroa (1986) 41 Cal.three dimensional 714 , 224 Cal.Rptr. 719; 715 P.2d 680 [Crim. Zero. 24252. Finest Judge out-of California. April seven, 1986.]

(Viewpoint because of the Bird, C. J., that have Mosk, Broussard, Grodin, JJ., and you may Takei (Taketsugu), J., concurring. Separate concurring opinion by Reynoso, J., which have Lucas, J., concurring.)

John K. Van de- Kamp, Attorney General, Edward P. O’Brien, Assistant Lawyer General, Derald Age. Granberg and you will Robert Roentgen. Granucci, Deputy Attorneys Standard, to own Plaintiff and Respondent.

The principal question presented through this desire is whether the fresh new demonstration legal, inside a beneficial prosecution toward income out-of unqualified ties, erred [41 Cal.three-dimensional 718] into the instructing the new jury this one «Corporation Promissory Notes» had been «securities» in the meaning of the corporate Ties Law. (Corp. Code, § 25000 et seq. fn. 1)

Stanford Rules College or university — Robert Top Rules Collection

Joseph and you can Dennis Figueroa focus out-of a view regarding conviction having one to matter from attempting to sell unqualified securities. (§§ 25110, 25540.) The fresh new jury deadlocked to your thirteen even more matters, 7 alleged against Joseph and you will five facing Dennis. After that, a great mistrial are declared on the individuals matters, and additionally they was indeed ignored to your realizing that they might be noticed from the court to possess restitution motives. Each other appellants received regards to probation that have requirements as well as restitution, a dangling state jail identity, and you may community solution.

Inside mid-March from 1979, Arlo Kurrle responded to a promotion which had starred in the San Jose Mercury News. This new offer stated «Solar & Times Business. Lover desired which have $7,one hundred thousand or more. Productive otherwise nonactive.» Kurrle called among one or two phone numbers placed in the brand new ad and talked to Joseph Figueroa, exactly who discussed a current insulation team and his wish to develop with the solar energy.

Kurrle satisfied Joseph and his online payday NC man, Dennis, 24 hours later. Brand new Figueroas told Kurrle throughout the Figueroa Insulation & Opportunity Co., Inc. (Insulation) at which Dennis is actually chairman. The latest solar power organization would getting a company. Kurrle been aware of several other companies, Figueroa Monetary Insurance rates Qualities, Inc. (Insurance) and you can Figueroa Business & Financial Experts (Financial).

Joseph and Dennis recommended you to definitely Kurrle invest $ten,000 within their business. The money was to be taken toward purchase of insulation equipment additionally the having phones accustomed obtain financing users.

During the basic fulfilling, Kurrle and Joseph discussed if Kurrle would be to become energetic in the the business. Kurrle shown need for that have a direct role, maybe regarding sales otherwise administration portion.

A few days later on, Kurrle entitled Joseph and you may offered to provide the company $ten,100000. Discover no discussion on which setting Kurrle’s investment [41 Cal.3d 719] manage take, but Kurrle «are thought in terms of financing . that will be reported.» From inside the dialogue, Joseph advised Kurrle he could be a police in a single of Figueroa firms.

Across the 2nd per month, Kurrle reduced the money toward Figueroas inside the five independent payments evidenced from the four dos-season notes. fn. 2 The notes were to earn ten percent appeal per year. Kurrle had the choice to bring fee from inside the bucks otherwise shares of the business. The newest next loan repayment, having $dos,500, constituted the basis towards the charges on which brand new Figueroas was ultimately convicted. fn. 3 Kurrle produced that loan giving the fresh new Figueroas a check payable so you’re able to Dennis. The mortgage try seen by the a «Enterprise Promissory Note» out-of Insulation which was signed by the Dennis. Inside the related area they said:

On the Really worth Received, on or In advance of 2 yrs immediately after date, rather than elegance The brand new Figueroa Insulation & Energy Company, Inc., intends to shell out on the acquisition regarding Mr. Arlo Kurrle, off San Jose, Ca otherwise at their house or office. [¶] The sum of $2,500 several thousand bucks & Five hundred at the rate off 10% per cent annum up to repaid. . [¶] . Their [sic] agreed and you will knew, that this firm notice is all owed a keen [sic] payable when you look at the two years out of big date of this mention as well as [sic] then conformed and you can know, you to definitely attention is going to be paid back yearly [sic] every year, however, all the owed and you will payable April 27th, 1981. . «